German Surrogate Twins - End of Legal Battle in Sight After 2 years

German Surrogate Twins born in India may finally be able to go home with both of their parents, of which one parent has had to remain in India for almost two years.  Ladies and gentleman, this is a cautionary tale of a couple wanting to be parents so badly that proper legal advice was not obtained beforehand.  You MUST check the laws of where you child is being born AND where you reside.  You cannot and should be taking advice from centers who tell you that things will work out - they have in the past.  You need solid legal guidance that makes certain things will go smoothly, as Murphy's Law never fails. 

 Here is where the case now stands:

"New Delhi, Jan 20 (PTI) The Supreme Court today allowed a German couple to approach the government of Germany to go in for an "inter-country" adoption of the twins born to them from a surrogate Indian woman.

A bench of Justices G S Singhvi and Asok Kumar Ganguly granted the permission after senior counsel L Nageswara Rao, appearing for the couple, sought 10 days time to go through the procedure as it involved certain intricacies.

Appearing on behalf of the Centre, Solicitor General Gopal Subramanaiam assured the apex court that the government "would extend all possible assistance to the petitioner (couple) to facilitate the adoption on humanatarian considation.

On the basis of the undertaking given by the couple and the Centre, the apex court posted the matter for further hearing after a fortnight."

Again, this is not a done deal, but it looks as if an end is in sight.  Good luck to them!

FRIDAY LEGAL UPDATES - Criminals & Adoption, Battle over Surrogacy, & CA Same Sex Bill Passes

TGIF!   I hope that those who are celebrating Labor Day this long weekend have a great time - I know I will. 

New York - A history of crime and drug addiction spanning two decades should not bar a man from being able to adopt, so says a New York judge who credited the man's attempt to turn his life around.  This ruling will allow this man and his wife to be placed on the adoption list.  His last conviction was 1995, and he claims to be clean and sober since 2000 when he was released from prison.  Many think it was a good decision - what about you?  I know what Bill O'Reilly would say. 

California - Legislation authored by Senator Mark Leno that resolves ambiguities about how out-of-state same-sex marriages will be recognized in California passed the Assembly today with a 44-27 vote.

Senate Bill 54 bill clarifies that same-sex couples who married outside of California before Proposition 8 went into effect last year are recognized as married spouses, not unlike the 18,000 same-sex marriages performed in California. The legislation also confirms that same-sex couples who married outside California after Prop 8 went into effect on November 5, 2008, or plan to do so in the future, must receive the same rights, protections, benefits, obligations and responsibilities afforded to opposite-sex spouses, with the sole exception of the designation of "marriage."

Australia -  Couples dealing with infertility in Melbourne and the state of Victoria, Australia, will now require that all couples wanting to go through IVF first have a background police check.   Should the background check find any convictions for serious sex or violent crimes, past incidents of having children taken out of their care, or any other crime that is considered a potential risk to children – IVF should be forbidden to the couple.

As stated in the article, I also agree that someone with serious sex or violent crime in their past shouldn’t be raising kids; however, are they going to force everyone else in Victoria to use birth control? And only allow people to have children if they pass background checks?  Unlikely!

This law is unfairly targeting couples with infertility. It’s discrimination, and I too think it’s blatantly wrong.

Prague -    The Justice Ministry is seeking changes to legislation which would affect the legal rights of surrogate and biological mothers.

Under current Czech law, biological mothers are not guaranteed parental rights to a child born to a surrogate. The surrogate mother could gain custody rights to the child she carries and delivers.

The Justice Ministry wants to change this part of the law. "I've been thinking about changing the law since May. In the course of my career, I've met a number of clients interested in the issue," Minister for Justice Daniela Kovářová told Aktuálně.cz.

The Czech legal system permits surrogate motherhood but has no law dealing specifically with the issue.

BelgiumA Belgian couple who commissioned a surrogate mother to carry a baby for them are to appeal against a Dutch ruling awarding custody of the child to a Dutch family who bought her over the internet.

The girl’s biological father had sought a surrogate mother because his own wife was infertile. Baby Donna was born in 2005 using his sperm. However instead of handing over the baby as agreed, the surrogate mother said she had miscarried and sold the baby to a Dutch couple in Leusden.

Since then, baby Donna has been the subject of a string of court cases in Belgium and the Netherlands. Last year, a court in Arnhem gave the man the right to visit his biological child but turned down his demand that the child be returned to him.

The Belgian couple, who live in Antwerp, have always regarded themselves as the child's real parents. They call her Valentina.

Don't forget that Surrogacy Lawyer, Theresa M. Erickson, is conducting an online seminar about Surrogacy and Egg Donation to air on September 23, 2009

For additional information on The Surrogacy & Egg Donation Seminar please contact Sabrina Scialpi at 858-748-4133 or visit
www.ericksonlaw.net/surrogacy_egg_donation_seminar.html

Surrogacy and Egg Donation Online Seminar Hosted by California Surrogacy Lawyer Theresa Erickson

Surrogacy Lawyer, Theresa M. Erickson, is conducting an online seminar about Surrogacy and Egg Donation to air on September 23, 2009. “We realized there is a need for information on the process of Surrogacy and Egg Donation.  We also realize that with the current state of the economy, people just don’t have the funds or time it takes to travel to a conference, with that in mind we are holding an online seminar that anyone with a computer can attend,” states Theresa M. Erickson, Surrogacy Lawyer, CEO and founder of Conceptual Options. 

This Surrogacy & Egg Donation Seminar is aimed at informing and educating those suffering from infertility on the possibilities that exist for family building.  The topics to be discussed include explaining the process of third party assisted reproduction, as well as helping alleviate the uncertainty of the journey, such as medical insurance issues, obtaining birth certificates and passports, citizenship issues, and taking your baby home.  Attendees will also receive a “goodie bag”  for attending via mail after the seminar.

“During these times of uncertainty and with the recent media coverage of surrogacy and egg donation, we are certain that these informational seminars will help dispel some of the miss-information that is being dispensed by the uninformed.  Assisted reproduction is a safe, legal and effective way for those who are unable to build their family through traditional methods,” states Surrogacy Lawyer Erickson.

We have combined our drawing for a Free Egg Donation Cycle with our recent conference in Genève, Switzerland.  One lucky seminar attendee from these two events will be awarded a Free Egg Donation Cycle, which can also be used in conjunction with someone using a surrogate.  “Dr. David Smotrich and La Jolla IVF have generously given their services for this Free Egg Donation cycle, while Conceptual Options is providing the egg donor and cycle coordination.  The surrogacy and egg donation law firms of Myers & O’Hara and Erickson Law will be providing free legal representation for the egg donation cycle and Egg Donation Lawyer Theresa M. Erickson will be sponsoring all of the donor medications,” states Ms. Erickson. 

The keynote speaker at this seminar will be Surrogacy lawyer Theresa M. Erickson.  Ms Erickson is a globally recognized expert in this specialized area of law. Attorney Erickson is also involved in this community by volunteering her time for as a board member of the American Fertility Association and as the legal director of Parents Via Egg Donation, while sponsoring events that promote awareness in this field.  She is also the author of Assisted Reproduction, the Complete Guide to Having a Baby with the Help of a Third Party. Her next book is currently being finalized for publication.

For additional information on The Surrogacy & Egg Donation Seminar please contact Sabrina Scialpi at 858-748-4133 or visit
www.ericksonlaw.net/surrogacy_egg_donation_seminar.html

 

 

Top Ten Questions to Ask Before Signing Up with an IVF Clinic, Law Office, or Agency as a Surrogate

As I was reviewing some incoming emails this week, I received one from a woman who could not decide how to move forward in becoming a surrogate.  First, she went on the internet, then she went onto Craigslist, where she found several ads declaring why they were the best.  So, in order to help her and others looking into becoming a surrogate, here are ten things you need to think about first:

1. Contact a Reproductive Lawyer or IVF Clinic for recommendations - the lawyers and the doctors are the licensed professionals in this field, as are the psychologists, and they can often give good advice on where to begin your journey.  You might also find a lawyer you want to work with when it becomes time to sign and review agreements with Intended Parents.

2. What if the lawyer or clinic has their own agency for matching surrogates with parents?  Well, I myself own an agency, so I can speak clearly to the potential conflicts of interest that can arise between you and the agency or the clinic; however, here are a few things to remember:

             a. Doctors and lawyers are licensed professionals who have licenses that they have worked hard to obtain and maintain.  At least in my office, surrogates always get their own attorneys, their own psychologist, and their own support separate from me.  But remember, doctors are not lawyers just as lawyers are not doctors - it is that simple. 

             b. If an IVF physician has an agency, how is their money held for their surrogates?  It is unlikely that they are licensed and bonded escrow holders, and they are not attorneys whose clients are protected by the state bar's client security fund, so ask that question.  Physicians do not have the same protections as the attorney's trust account does. 

             c. With an IVF Physician, what happens at 12 weeks when you are released to your OB physician?  Do they have the staff to do that, and who is that?  How does the clinic still handle and facilitate your arrangement, if at all?  Make sure you are being supported all the way to the end, not just until the pregnancy reaches the first trimester.   

            d. Now, as for your health and physical well being, the other issue that some have is the conflict of interest that a doctor has with his patient, the surrogate, and his patient, the Intended Parents.  Again, as it has to do with your health and well-being, make certain that you get independent legal representation and ask questions.  It is your body and your health, so you must be diligent in making certain that you are being protected too.  Many, many IVF Physicians are wonderful, caring doctors, but you must ask questions to ensure you are being protected.  Also, ask what their success rates are and how long they have been practicing IVF?

3.  Agencies - yes, they are unregulated, unlicensed, etc. - but, speak with them too - better yet, meet with them in their office and meet the staff.  Some are very reputable.  Ask a reproductive lawyer or IVF clinic for recommendations.  Then, call and interview them.  Ask them the following:

             a.  Are they a match making service only, or do they provide support throughout the entire process through delivery and beyond?

             b. How are their surrogates and donors funds held?  Make certain that they are held by an escrow company or by an attorney.

             c.  What type of support do they provide?  Get specifics.  What type of staff do they have and how many people are there for you in the office?

             d. Do they have parents waiting?  If not, how long will you have to wait?  Remember, promises of being matched immediately are empty, as each case if different.  Also, ask how many matches they do per year and per month. 

             e. How long have they been in business?  Can you speak with other surrogates?

             f.  Agencies are not medical providers, but the reputable ones know what they are doing and are instrumental in helping you select a physician, psychologist, etc., as well as helping you get answers when the medical aspect is unclear.  Don't think that you will be left with inadequate medical care if you go through an agency.

             g. Reputable agencies are insured against Errors & Omissions Insurance.  Ask if they carry it.

             h. Does the agency have surrogate support group meetings and/or annual parties?  These are always alot of fun, and there are usually prizes for the winners of contests.  This is also a great way to meet other women like yourself who are going through many of the same things.

4.  Beware of agencies, clinics or law offices that claim that they work with high profile clients and celebrities.  Remember, if that were really the case, you would not know about it - that is not information one should or would want to share if that is the case.  No one wants what Sarah Jessica Parker's surrogate went through.  And, don't be drawn in by the expectation of working with a celebrity. 

5. Who is going to be there 24 hours a day to answer questions or take my call in the case of an emergency?  Not just during the first trimester, but throughout the entire pregnancy and at the end.  Ask if there is anyone that does that in the office of the agency, lawyer, or doctor.  This is very important. 

6.  Although there are many things that you need to do yourself, such as deal with your insurance or make doctor appointments, as you are the patient, is there going to be someone there to help you navigate this new and unknown journey.

7.  Is the clinic, agency or law office going to screen your intended parents?  Do your intended parents get a background check and a psychological education session to make certain we are a good match?

8.  Is the agency, law office or clinic going to support me when I need it the most?  For example, my intended parents don't pay a medical bill?  Will they support me in getting this resolved?  Will they help me write letters or handle it legally?  Remember, the agreement is between you and your intended parents, but you will need support.   What a good clinic, agency or law office will do is provide you with support throughout the entire pregnancy, even if you think you may not need it.  In fact, they should be acting as a neutral third party for any uncomfortable situations that may arise with your intended parents so that the situation can be resolved without any bad feelings between the parties.  They should also have the professional experience (not just that I am a doctor, lawyer or I have been a surrogate once before) to know of the possible issues that can arise and how they can be resolved with the least amount of drama.  

9. Does the clinic or agency or law office provide a blanket agreement (one that they have prepared and given to you and your intended parents ) with no counsel?  If so, be careful.  A contract should be drafted by an attorney for the intended parents that is drafted specifically for your case.  You should then review with an independent attorney to ensure that is covers your particular situation.

10. Last important point is that is in no way an exhaustive list.  Use your head and use your gut before agreeing to anything.  Making a list of pros and cons is also helpful before you select the clinic, agency or law office that you are going to work with.  Good luck. 

Surrogacy Law Radio Show Link & Information

Today I did a great interview with Creating A Family that has alot of information on Surrogacy for everyone.   The host, Dawn Davenport, asked great questions, and I think that you will learn alot.  Click Here for the entire show from today, July 8, 2009.

This is also a reminder that I will be hosting my own show tomorrow at 8:30 PST on surrogacy, egg donation, and maybe more on Michael Jackson and California Law.  Please feel free to call in or email me with any questions ahead of time.  Click Here for Show Information.

Click Here to subscribe to my blog.