Blunder at top clinic sparks fresh IVF fears - How to Protect Yourself

With the new blunder discovered at a UK clinic, more patients are afraid of what if it happens to them....

In fact, as discussed by By Susie Mesure in The Independent, donor sperm with chromosomal abnormalities went unscreened, raising the risk of miscarriage and birth. defects. 

"A serious blunder at one of Britain's top fertility clinics dramatically increased the risk its patients would suffer a miscarriage or give birth to a child with serious health problems, sparking fresh fears about how IVF centres are run in the wake of a series of scandals."

In fact, "Fertility experts believe the LWC's error could be the "tip of the iceberg", and that it raises serious concerns about how the industry is regulated. It is the latest in a series of high-profile incidents, including a couple's last viable embryo being implanted into another woman, and eggs fertilised with the wrong sperm, forcing three couples' embryos to be destroyed."

"The blunder constituted the most severe mistake that a clinic can make, according to the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority, which regulates the multimillion-pound IVF sector. In future, the watchdog will name and shame clinics for similar incidents under new rules to expose mistakes and near misses."

Yes, mistakes do happen, and we need to keep an eye on regulations that will make this field of medicine as error free as possible.  In fact, there are many things that the fertility patient can do for themselves to ensure that they set themselves up for success versus the failures that we have seen in the UK, Ohio and even Louisiana.

I suggest to each one of my clients that following:

1. Make certain that your doctor and clinci is board certified and cleared by the FDA, including their lab being accredited.  Look to SARTCDC, and the AMA.

2. Speak with your clinic to understand how they label embryos, sperm, eggs, etc.  Also, ask questions regarding all testing provided by the clinic on embryos, sperm, and eggs.

3. Always check to see if there are any complaints against the clinic and/or the doctor;

4. Ask the clinic if they have a policy for disclosing mistakes or errors to patients?  Also, what is their history of any such mistakes/errors.

5. DO NOT BE AFRAID to ASK QUESTIONS - no question is stupid or silly. 

For more information, also look to Dawn Davenport's article on this issue.

Woman Implanted with Wrong Embryo & Carrying Baby to Term for Couple

A woman in Ohio was implanted with the wrong embryo eight months ago, and she and her husband decided to keep the pregnancy, despite the fact that they know that they will be saying "hello and goodbye" at the same time to the child that is not theirs. 

According to the couple, when they received the call from the doctor telling them that they were pregnant, the doctor also told them in the same sentence that it was the wrong embryo.  The doctor gave them the option to abort; however, they could not go against their religious beliefs.  I find this couple to be an honorable couple, and I hope that their journey ends well.  It appears that they intend to use their remaining embryos in a gestational carrier very soon, as the woman can no longer carry. 

A very sad story, and we hope them, as well as the child and his family, the best.  As for the IVF doctor and clinic, it was honorable that they informed the couple right away unlike Dr. Katz in California, who has since lost his license and who did not inform the woman until the child was 10 months old.  Unfortunately, providing the information right away still does not take away the damage that was done.

I am not sure what to say on this one.  I think this couple is incredible, but what an experience.  What do you think?

Subscribe to my blog here

Top Ten Questions to Ask Before Signing Up with an IVF Clinic, Law Office, or Agency as a Surrogate

As I was reviewing some incoming emails this week, I received one from a woman who could not decide how to move forward in becoming a surrogate.  First, she went on the internet, then she went onto Craigslist, where she found several ads declaring why they were the best.  So, in order to help her and others looking into becoming a surrogate, here are ten things you need to think about first:

1. Contact a Reproductive Lawyer or IVF Clinic for recommendations - the lawyers and the doctors are the licensed professionals in this field, as are the psychologists, and they can often give good advice on where to begin your journey.  You might also find a lawyer you want to work with when it becomes time to sign and review agreements with Intended Parents.

2. What if the lawyer or clinic has their own agency for matching surrogates with parents?  Well, I myself own an agency, so I can speak clearly to the potential conflicts of interest that can arise between you and the agency or the clinic; however, here are a few things to remember:

             a. Doctors and lawyers are licensed professionals who have licenses that they have worked hard to obtain and maintain.  At least in my office, surrogates always get their own attorneys, their own psychologist, and their own support separate from me.  But remember, doctors are not lawyers just as lawyers are not doctors - it is that simple. 

             b. If an IVF physician has an agency, how is their money held for their surrogates?  It is unlikely that they are licensed and bonded escrow holders, and they are not attorneys whose clients are protected by the state bar's client security fund, so ask that question.  Physicians do not have the same protections as the attorney's trust account does. 

             c. With an IVF Physician, what happens at 12 weeks when you are released to your OB physician?  Do they have the staff to do that, and who is that?  How does the clinic still handle and facilitate your arrangement, if at all?  Make sure you are being supported all the way to the end, not just until the pregnancy reaches the first trimester.   

            d. Now, as for your health and physical well being, the other issue that some have is the conflict of interest that a doctor has with his patient, the surrogate, and his patient, the Intended Parents.  Again, as it has to do with your health and well-being, make certain that you get independent legal representation and ask questions.  It is your body and your health, so you must be diligent in making certain that you are being protected too.  Many, many IVF Physicians are wonderful, caring doctors, but you must ask questions to ensure you are being protected.  Also, ask what their success rates are and how long they have been practicing IVF?

3.  Agencies - yes, they are unregulated, unlicensed, etc. - but, speak with them too - better yet, meet with them in their office and meet the staff.  Some are very reputable.  Ask a reproductive lawyer or IVF clinic for recommendations.  Then, call and interview them.  Ask them the following:

             a.  Are they a match making service only, or do they provide support throughout the entire process through delivery and beyond?

             b. How are their surrogates and donors funds held?  Make certain that they are held by an escrow company or by an attorney.

             c.  What type of support do they provide?  Get specifics.  What type of staff do they have and how many people are there for you in the office?

             d. Do they have parents waiting?  If not, how long will you have to wait?  Remember, promises of being matched immediately are empty, as each case if different.  Also, ask how many matches they do per year and per month. 

             e. How long have they been in business?  Can you speak with other surrogates?

             f.  Agencies are not medical providers, but the reputable ones know what they are doing and are instrumental in helping you select a physician, psychologist, etc., as well as helping you get answers when the medical aspect is unclear.  Don't think that you will be left with inadequate medical care if you go through an agency.

             g. Reputable agencies are insured against Errors & Omissions Insurance.  Ask if they carry it.

             h. Does the agency have surrogate support group meetings and/or annual parties?  These are always alot of fun, and there are usually prizes for the winners of contests.  This is also a great way to meet other women like yourself who are going through many of the same things.

4.  Beware of agencies, clinics or law offices that claim that they work with high profile clients and celebrities.  Remember, if that were really the case, you would not know about it - that is not information one should or would want to share if that is the case.  No one wants what Sarah Jessica Parker's surrogate went through.  And, don't be drawn in by the expectation of working with a celebrity. 

5. Who is going to be there 24 hours a day to answer questions or take my call in the case of an emergency?  Not just during the first trimester, but throughout the entire pregnancy and at the end.  Ask if there is anyone that does that in the office of the agency, lawyer, or doctor.  This is very important. 

6.  Although there are many things that you need to do yourself, such as deal with your insurance or make doctor appointments, as you are the patient, is there going to be someone there to help you navigate this new and unknown journey.

7.  Is the clinic, agency or law office going to screen your intended parents?  Do your intended parents get a background check and a psychological education session to make certain we are a good match?

8.  Is the agency, law office or clinic going to support me when I need it the most?  For example, my intended parents don't pay a medical bill?  Will they support me in getting this resolved?  Will they help me write letters or handle it legally?  Remember, the agreement is between you and your intended parents, but you will need support.   What a good clinic, agency or law office will do is provide you with support throughout the entire pregnancy, even if you think you may not need it.  In fact, they should be acting as a neutral third party for any uncomfortable situations that may arise with your intended parents so that the situation can be resolved without any bad feelings between the parties.  They should also have the professional experience (not just that I am a doctor, lawyer or I have been a surrogate once before) to know of the possible issues that can arise and how they can be resolved with the least amount of drama.  

9. Does the clinic or agency or law office provide a blanket agreement (one that they have prepared and given to you and your intended parents ) with no counsel?  If so, be careful.  A contract should be drafted by an attorney for the intended parents that is drafted specifically for your case.  You should then review with an independent attorney to ensure that is covers your particular situation.

10. Last important point is that is in no way an exhaustive list.  Use your head and use your gut before agreeing to anything.  Making a list of pros and cons is also helpful before you select the clinic, agency or law office that you are going to work with.  Good luck. 

Tips for Those Dealing with Infertility

Although most of my clients come to me after years of struggling with infertility to such as degree that they have to move into the area of third party reproduction; however, today, I wanted to provide some guidance to those who are "newbies."  In fact, I found a great blog that provides alot of useful information that one can refer back to over and over.  It is found at Quips & Tips for Couples Coping with Infertility

Some of the guidance that people at all stages should follow are as follows courtesy of this blog hostess:

"Tips for In Vitro Fertilization - IVF

Arm yourself with info, but don’t get alarmed. Our IVF doctor gave us a sheath of info and consent forms, and some of it revolves around the possible hazards of the egg retrieval and implantation surgeries. They list the possible problems (infection, intestinal punctures) and say “this is not to alarm or scare you!” One tip for IVF is to get all the info you can…but don’t let it freak you out.

Talk to couples who’ve tried IVF. When you get first-hand experiences, you’ll have more info than you ever wanted! To connect with other couples coping with infertility, ask your fertility specialist if they know of any support groups in nearby hospitals or communities. If you’re brave enough, you can ask your friends and family…and find blogs or websites like these!

Read fertility books. Current books about IVF, donor sperm, IUI, and natural treatments for infertility are great ways to learn about the procedure. The more you know about IVF, the more comfortable you’ll feel, which is why these tips for in vitro fertilization are so important.

Read Fertility Plus’ article called IVF Hints. I didn’t agree about the “don’t talk to your partner about his role, as this causes stress” part, but I think it depends on each couple. Everyone copes with infertility differently! If stress leads to performance anxiety, then by all means keep him calm…but if he’s not involved in the sperm donor process, then talk as much as you need!

Do a mock IVF transfer? This is one of the tips for in vitro fertilization suggested by Fertility Plus, but I don’t think we’ll do it. It may be good in theory, but I suspect it’ll cost more time, money, and energy than I can spare. A mock IVF transfer can give the fertility specialist an idea of the depth of your uterus, so when the real time comes, they’re ready.

Be prepared for anything. I’m prepared for pain, discomfort, mood swings, and the fact that this IVF could lead to pregnancy…or another disappointment. I’m prepared for things I can’t even fathom right now! I’m ready for anything.

Plan something fun for after the transfer! Some fertility specialists say to relax right after the egg and sperm are placed, while other say it’s not scientifically proven that increases the success of in vitro fertilization. My tip for a successful IVF is to rent a few of your favorite or new DVDs, make popcorn, snuggle up with your sweetie, and take a day or two off! Give yourself something enjoyable to look forward to.

Plan something fun for after the pregnancy test. If my in vitro fertilization isn’t successful, I’m getting laser eye surgery. Having 20/20 or better vision isn’t as good as a baby, but at least it’s something to look forward to!

What are your tips for or thoughts about in vitro fertilization? I’d love to hear from you - please comment below. Is IVF painful? How many times did you try? Did it eventually work for you? What would you do differently?"

Subscribe to my blog at: http://www.surrogacyeggdonorblog.com/subscribe.html

FRIDAY LEGAL UPDATES - Lesbian Couple Suing for Access to IVF & Woman Suing for Loss of Last Embryo

Unfortunately, due to my attendance at the Donor Egg Meeting in South Carolina, today’s updates are minimal. Hopefully, this conference will give me plenty to blog about next week, so stay tuned.

UK - Lesbians Want Access to IVF from NHS. The Sun is reporting the following: “Caroline Harris and Julie McMullan claimed discrimination and breach of human rights after they were rejected for IVF treatment. They say they suffered “distress and anxiety” — and ran up a bill of £11,000 paying for private care.

They want a judge to review the decision by NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde .  The couple, whose challenge is backed by equality officials, also want the health board to order fertility treatment for Caroline.

NHS chiefs insist the service, which costs £3,300 a time, is for couples who have tried in vain to conceive in the normal way. In papers lodged at the Court of Session in Edinburgh, they claim Caroline and Julie do not fit the definition of an infertile couple.

But the women claim official rules do not mention that only same-sex couples can get treatment.”

Furthermore, “Last night, the Equality and Human Rights Commission Scotland — who are backing the women — said that “discrimination of this type is unlawful.”

Spokeswoman Lynn Welsh added: ‘It will not be tolerated in a fair society. Equality means that while no one has an absolute right to receive treatment, the services provided by the NHS have to be available to everyone equally.’

A full hearing is expected at a later date. “

Click Here for Complete Article

Australia – An Australian woman claims her fertility lost her last embryo, thereby thwarting her chances at motherhood – and she is suing for pain and suffering. The article provides details as follows: “The woman, said to be in her late 40s, alleges Melbourne IVF staff allowed her potential baby to be destroyed.

She claims to have paid storage fees for years to preserve on ice the last of 13 embryos created during infertility treatment in 2003 and 2004.

But the embryo allegedly couldn't be found for a final round of treatment in 2007.

The woman has launched legal action in the County Court against Melbourne IVF, which is expected to defend the claim.

Court documents filed by the woman's lawyers this week claim the would-be mom started IVF treatment in October 2003.

A total of 31 eggs were harvested and 13 of the resulting embryos were frozen, the suit says.

The woman alleges Melbourne IVF's Dr. Geoffrey Clarke assured her one embryo would be kept in storage for later use.”

Click Here for Complete Article

Click Here for Another Article On This Case

Theresa M. Erickson, Esq.
Surrogacy Lawyer & Egg Donation Lawyer 
www.EricksonLaw.net

Subscribe to my blog at: http://www.surrogacyeggdonorblog.com/subscribe.html

 

California Legislator to Introduce Bill to Establish Stricter Standards on Fertility Clinics

State Senator Gloria Negrete McLeod (D-Chino) intends to introduce a measure that will establish accredidation standards and guidelines for the operation of fertility clinics.  The intent is to better protect the public because of the increasing number of surgical procedures being performed outside of the walls of a hospital.  The measure would essentially bring fertility clinics under the jurisdiction of the Medical Board of California requiring the establishment of standardized procedures and protocols to be followed in the event of complications and to govern emergency and urgent care situations.

This bill will also affect other clinics, such as plastic surgery centers.  This bill also recommends some additional requirements including disclosure; however, this just appears to be the first of many regulations to come after the wake of the octuplets. 

Click Here for Complete Article

Theresa M. Erickson, Esq.
Surrogacy Lawyer & Egg Donation Lawyer 
www.EricksonLaw.net

Subscribe to my blog at: http://www.surrogacyeggdonorblog.com/subscribe.html

 

California Legislator to Introduce Bill to Establish Stricter Standards on Fertility Clinics

State Senator Gloria Negrete McLeod (D-Chino) intends to introduce a measure that will establish accredidation standards and guidelines for the operation of fertility clinics.  The intent is to better protect the public because of the increasing number of surgical procedures being performed outside of the walls of a hospital.  The measure would essentially bring fertility clinics under the jurisdiction of the Medical Board of California requiring the establishment of standardized procedures and protocols to be followed in the event of complications and to govern emergency and urgent care situations.

This bill will also affect other clinics, such as plastic surgery centers.  This bill also recommends some additional requirements including disclosure; however, this just appears to be the first of many regulations to come after the wake of the octuplets. 

Click Here for Complete Article

Theresa M. Erickson, Esq.
Surrogacy Lawyer & Egg Donation Lawyer 
www.EricksonLaw.net

Subscribe to my blog at: http://www.surrogacyeggdonorblog.com/subscribe.html

 

FRIDAY LEGAL UPATES - Octuplets, Missouri Donor Legislation & Indian Surrogacy

 

A. Missouri – it appears that the Missouri legislature, headed by Cynthia Davis. In her bill (HB355) she is attempting to ban all anonymous donation (egg and sperm) in Missouri and give all donor-conceived offspring the right to access the donor’s identity at age 21.          In fact, she wants the child’s birth certificate reflect the biological parent’s name (yes, she called the donor a parent) and the donor parent’s name as well. She is not intending to create any legal relationship between donors and the offspring, but the use of the word PARENT is extremely disturbing. What do you think?

 

 

Click Here for the information on this bill HB355

Blog On Bill HB355

B. Octuplet Case – the ASRM is now considering to kick the octuplet doctor out of the society. What affect do you think this will really have? And, with his new case of quadruplets, why do patients keep seeking him out for treatment, especially with his (un)success rates?

Click Here for an Article on this Case in WSJ

Click Here for an Article on this Case in Union Tribune

Click Here for an Article on this Case in New York Post

C. India Surrogacy & a Legal Warning – I read an informative article on a warning to couples/individuals going to India for a surrogate mother. The article discusses what I have guessed all along, that pursuing surrogacy in India is still a risky process because there are still no comprehensive laws covering the practice. I am always concerned when people cut corners when they are in such a vulnerable and desperate state of mind. What do you think?

See article at www.theage.com.au

Theresa M. Erickson, Esq. www.ericksonlaw.net

 

 

 

 

 

Octuplets and Regulation - What Should We Do with Fertility Treatments?

I am still waiting for this controversy to finally die down, but it sure does not look that way with new information coming out about the mother and her fertility doctor.  But, today I want to stay away from that and look more to the regulations that everyone is literally screaming for at the top of their lungs.  I understand that everyone wants some control since it looks like the tax payers are ultimately going to pay the bill for her decisions, but I also want to make note of how regulations will also affect the millions of other fertility patients that do make sound decisions in their family planning.

First, in other countries that have regulations surrounding the number of embryos being implanted, I want to note that the government actually foots the bill for a certain number of IVF cycles - thereby giving patients an added assurance that they can try one embryo at a time because their government will pay for another (possibly) cycle.  Here, in the US, we do not have that luxury as this is a cash business.  Very few, if any states and insurance companies cover the costs of IVF.  These patients are then placed in the dilemma of not having enough funds to cover another cycle if this one does not work.

Now, with that in mind, I want to encourage everyone to look at the issue of regulations with an open mind, and look at what Dr. James A. Grifo, the program director of the New York University Fertility Center at the Langone Medical Center and a professor of obstetrics and gynecology at the university’s School of Medicine, has to say in the following piece:

"The fascination with the octuplets born last week has dominated the news media. But after the initial marvel of the miraculous feat faded, we were left wondering why an unemployed mother of six wanted more. Responses from around the country, and within the medical community, included cries of malpractice and demands for new laws regulating fertility treatment.

But where would this lead? A knee-jerk response to one outlier does not always prevent the next. Legislation about how to practice medicine threatens doctor-patient relations and has unintended consequences that may be worse than the actual problem. We live in a country that doesn’t regulate family size. If we were to decree a proper number, who would decide?

In 1992, Congress passed a law requiring fertility clinics to report their pregnancy rates. It came about because a rogue practitioner was telling patients the success rates of in vitro fertilization based on national statistics and neglecting to mention that his own clinic had none. Thus a national registry was born, financed by taxpayers. The clinics that refused were listed as non reporters, hardly a punishment.

But the implications of a government published report were unanticipated and it changed behavior. Since clinics were measured by pregnancy rates, there was incentive to implant more embryos into a patient — creating the unwanted consequence of a boom in twins and triplets.

The American Society of Reproductive Medicine and its subgroup, the Society for Assisted Reproductive Technologists, recognized the problem and published guidelines for the number of embryos to transfer to maximize pregnancy rates but minimize multiple gestation, especially triplets and beyond. We have now published three iterations of these guidelines since 1999 with a significant decline in the incidence of triplets and higher. This happened without laws being passed; it was simple cooperation of clinicians doing the right thing for positive change to happen.

Medicine cannot be practiced in a vacuum or by legislation. It requires a patient and physician dialogue, it requires decision-making that minimizes risk and maximizes good outcome, and it requires patients and physicians to make good decisions. Indeed, that is already happening but that story is lost in the tsunami of one unusual case whose facts are not known."

Click Here for the Complete Article

Theresa M. Erickson, Esq.
Surrogacy Lawyer & Egg Donation Lawyer 
www.EricksonLaw.net

Subscribe to my blog at: http://www.surrogacyeggdonorblog.com/subscribe.html

Octuplets Birth Continues to Cause "Outrage" - What Do You Think?

I do hate stories such as this that capture so much media attention.  They actually take away attention from all of the "good" stories out there, such as the couple who conquered their infertility after five tries at IVF.  Just today I read scores of articles calling the birth an outrage and the actions of the doctor criminal.  I am still on the fence about this entire story, and I am withholding judgment at this point, but I am curious to see what others are thinking.

Click Here for Article from LA Times - Octuplets' birth spawns outrage

Click Here for a Press Release from an IVF Physician in Georgia

Click Here for Blog from San Diego IVF Physician

Theresa M. Erickson, Esq.
Surrogacy Lawyer & Egg Donation Lawyer 
www.EricksonLaw.net

Subscribe to my blog at: http://www.surrogacyeggdonorblog.com/subscribe.html

The Octuplets and Regulations - What Should We Do?

I have been trying to show restraint with my opinion on the octuplets because I believe strongly in reproductive freedom for everyone in America, and I also understand an individuals strong desire for children.  But, I really enjoyed the piece written by George Dvorsky on the Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies Blog.  He makes quite a few good points involving common sense and restraint.  As many have cited, he wants ASRM to set up and give their guidelines some teeth.  I am not certain if that will happen or if it should happen, but let me know what you think. 

"Like a lot of people last week, I was shocked to find out that Nadya Suleman, the mother of the octuplets born last week in Los Angeles, already has 6 children—all between the ages of 2 and 7.

And that she is a single mother who has already filed for bankruptcy, and that she is a self-described “professional student” who lives off education grants and parental money.....

Looking at this case one gets the feeling that some fertility clinics look upon their patients as nothing more than customers. Given the nature of their work, however, this attitude will simply not do.

A lassez-faire approach to repro-tech won’t work to protect the interests of those hoping to use these technologies and to protect those lives that are created as a result. I agree that regulation should be very liberal and accommodating to a diverse set of interests, but complete de-regulation would be both dangerous and facile.

But establishing regulations and guidelines is one thing, enforcing it is quite another.

In some cases, this one included, it would be perfectly reasonable for the state to intervene and deny access, or at the very least compel clinics to follow a strict set of guidelines to prevent this sort of thing from happening. It’s time to empower groups like the ASRM—particularly now as new reproductive technologies are emerging quickly. This way, fertility clinics will be compelled to follow the rules and be held accountable for their actions.

It’s clear that this has to happen. Clinics won’t regulate themselves.

But why should we have expected them to? They’re not the ones who now have to raise these children. "

Click Here For Complete Article

See Also Article by the Reproductive Rights Prof Blog

Theresa M. Erickson, Esq.
Surrogacy Lawyer & Egg Donation Lawyer 
www.EricksonLaw.net

Subscribe to my blog at: http://www.surrogacyeggdonorblog.com/subscribe.html