Surrogacy & The Media - Why is it always so negative?

Surrogacy gets a bad rap from the media in general, as they only seem to want to post stories that are negative or involving a celebrity.  In fact, the blogsphere was in full swing yesterday after NY Times posted an article that was not so nice.  It was called Building a Baby, With Few Ground Rules, and it was absolutely depressing.  The piece would almost make anyone run from surrogacy - myself included; however, the most important point to take from that article is that couples, surrogates and egg donors need to make certain that they do the right things with the right team and professionals

In fact, Kathy Benardo of Northeast Assisted Fertility Group stated it very nicely when she clarifies that it speaks of only bad surrogacies, while the piece only slightly makes the point that most surrogacies go well.  What she also addressed is that "The Michigan and Indiana cases discussed did not follow the proper legal or medical protocols at all; in fact, the egregiousness is stunning. These surrogacy cases should have never happened in the first place."   Yes,I agree, Kathy, wholeheratedly. 

Surrogacy, despite what the naysayers may say, is not an unregulated Wild West mentality, although the article does make one think that.  When done correctly, Surrogacy is an exciting option for infertile couples and individuals, as well as LGBT couples who could otherwise not have a child, to have the family that they always dreamt of

Just look to the posts by a set of hopeful Intended Parents who have been through so much to have their baby - My Journey to Myles and Beyond.  Just look at the timeline on the side.  They certainly are upset with the article that over sensationalizes what surrogacy is all about.  The Intended Mother puts her heart on the line, and it is worth a read.

Let me know your thoughts.  We will take up Reproductive Tourism this week again involving Canada and the rules that are being violated when working in that country, so keep watching. 

 

 

The Egg Donation and Surrogacy Professional Association Meets with Assisted Reproduction Experts

Self-Regulation versus legislation - what is the answer?  What are your thoughts regarding the fertility industry?  Let us know.  

Here is the press release as follows:

"ORLANDO, FL, June 02, 2009 /24-7PressRelease/ -- Recently, in response to the negative press generated by the Octomom and Surrogenesis debacles, the Egg Donation and Surrogacy Professional Association members ("EDSPA") presented the organization's current status and future plans to a multi-disciplined group of internationally recognized assisted reproduction professionals. Among its many offerings, this non-profit organization provides safe practices guidelines to third party reproduction professionals.

The meeting attendees included representatives from the American Society of Reproductive Medicine, RESOLVE, the American Fertility Association, the American Bar Association, Egg Donor Agency owners, Surrogacy Agency owners in addition to attorneys who practices are limited to reproductive law.

The meeting also provided an opportunity for EDSPA to introduce its dispute resolution program for the infertile clients of third party reproduction professionals. This program, believed to be the only one of its kind in the infertility industry, will permit aggrieved clients to resolve disputes with their service providers in a non-litigious environment.

One of the meeting attendees, Maureen McBrien, a notable Boston family law attorney who authored Assisted Reproductive Technology: A Lawyer's Guide to Emerging Law and Science stated that "Right now, there is no regulation ... in general." Attorney McBrien offered her opinion that the best response might be for the industry to police itself. EDSPA could potentially act as a filter for agencies and be a place where intended parents, surrogates and egg donors could find security, she said.

About EDSPA

The Egg Donation and Surrogacy Professional Association accomplishes it's mission by providing a forum for education, communication and advocacy on behalf of patients, physicians, attorneys, agencies and affiliated professionals in the field of Third Party Family Formation."

Subscribe to my blog