Ohio Surrogacy Case Reaches Supreme Court

High court: Contract voided surrogate mother's right to triplets

Associated Press - December 20, 2007 1:15 PM ET

COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) - A divided Ohio Supreme Court has ruled that a surrogate mother who kept triplets who weren't biologically hers doesn't have the same rights as a parent.

In a 4-3 decision, the court says the Pennsylvania woman must abide by her contract with the triplets' biological father in Ohio.

Justice Paul Pfeifer wrote in yeserday's majority opinion that it's too soon to say if the contract had indeed been breached and damages should be rewarded.

The court's ruling provides only the initials of the parties to protect the identity of the children. The initials match those of a surrogate mother and a male Cleveland State University professor who have been embroiled in a legal battle over triplets born in Erie, Pennsylvania, in 2003.


Tags:

Intended Parents Beware!

This event is just one example of why every party to a surrogacy or egg donation needs to protect themselves with a team of professionals. 

COLUMBIA, S.C.  —  A South Carolina woman accused of promising couples she would be their surrogate mother has been charged with bilking at least six people out of $14,000, police said Thursday.

Jessica O'Donnell, 28, used the Internet to lure couples desperate to have children, prosecutors said. She was charged with obtaining money under false pretenses and was being held Thursday on $140,000 bail.

According to Greenwood County sheriff's investigators, O'Donnell told people to send sperm in a plastic cup and use ice packs and a cooler to preserve the fluids. She said she would then have a friend who is a nurse inseminate her.

Police found several coolers at O'Donnell's home in the small town of Hodges, about 80 miles northwest of Columbia.

O'Donnell's husband, Daniel, 28, also has been charged with obtaining money under false pretenses, said Maj. John Murray of the Greenwood County Sheriff's Office. He was scheduled to be arraigned Thursday.

Murray said he doesn't think the O'Donnells have hired an attorney. A woman who answered the telephone at the couple's home hung up when asked about Jessica O'Donnell. A subsequent message was not returned.

According to police reports, victims of the scam were from Tennessee, New York, Alabama, Minnesota and Pennsylvania, but their names were not released. They told investigators they connected with O'Donnell through an Internet site.

An Internet blog also was created to warn others about O'Donnell.

O'Donnell claims she is 15 weeks pregnant with her husband's child, Murray said. The couple has a 1-year-old daughter and a 12-year-old son, who are living with Jessica O'Donnell's parents in Hodges, Murray said.

Investigators are awaiting test results to determine whether she actually is pregnant.

For complete link, click here: http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,316758,00.html

Tags:

Sperm Donor Ordered to Pay Support - Counsel Needed!

This is a perfect example of why you need legal counsel before you donate sperm!

Sunday , December 02, 2007

FC1

ADVERTISEMENT

A New York doctor who donated his sperm to help a gay colleague conceive has been ordered to pay child support for the boy, now an 18-year-old living in Oregon, the New York Post reported Sunday.

The donor was a married doctor at a Long Island hospital in the late 1980s when he donated his sperm to a female hospital resident who was trying to have a baby with her lesbian partner, the Post reported. Although the donor gave up all claims and rights to the child, he allowed his name to be put on the birth certificate.

Click here for the complete article: http://www.nypost.com/seven/12022007/news/regionalnews/perm_wail_by_donor_901096.htm

Australia - Senator Wins Paternity Battle

Carol Nader
December 3, 2007

STEPHEN Conroy has won legal recognition as the father of his baby daughter, born one year ago through a surrogacy arrangement in Sydney.

And the incoming federal Communications Minister has urged the State Government to change the law to make it easier for other infertile couples to become parents.

Senator Conroy has spoken exclusively to The Age about how the flaws and anomalies in Victorian fertility legislation are putting barriers in the way of childless couples.

He said the law had not kept up with science and was failing to adequately protect children conceived through surrogacy.

"A number of changes that have been created by science have been ignored by the law, and that's led to circumstances like my own, where I was forced to go interstate to have a child through surrogacy," he said. "This caused increased stress, increased cost, and a whole range of legal complications."

Continue Reading...
Tags:

New Development in Florida Surrogate Battle

First Coast News

JACKSONVILLE, FL -- There are new developments in the birth battle between an Orlando-area couple and a surrogate mother on the First Coast. On Thursday, a judge denied a motion to stay an earlier ruling in the case.

Tom Lamitina and his wife hired Stephanie Eckard over the Internet to be their surrogate. She decided to keep the baby.

Last month, the judge ruled that under Florida law, Lamitina is merely a sperm donor and not the baby's father. The lamitinas have appealed the ruling. Their lawyer said that he also plans to file a civil case against Eckard.

http://www.firstcoastnews.com/news/local/news-article.aspx?storyid=96853

Tags: